Power to the People

I was amused to read last Tuesday (6th April, 2010) of the Federal Appeals Court's decision, which overturned a judgment against Comcast. Not that I have anything to do with Comcast, you understand; it's more of a personal, anti-authority thing. Somehow, it appeals to me that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has effectively been told it has no right to tell ISPs how to manage their networks.

The essence of this ruling is surely a clear statement that the FCC, although it has delegated (by Congress) regulatory authority over the provision of telecommunications services, does not have the same authority over Internet services. In fact, it has absolutely no authority in that regard.

Some reports have suggested this will be the end of the FCC's quest for broadband and net-neutrality regulation, because it has no jurisdiction over ISPs. I feel this is unlikely as an institution like the FCC isn't going to just curl up and expire; no sir, it's going to fight back!

What I also found interesting was the idea that, in order to gain control over ISPs as well as Telcos, the FCC might attempt to reclassify Internet access as a telecommunications service. Should that happen; prepare for years of legal wrangling and no short term outcome other than more smug attorneys.

Should we (in the United Kingdom in addition to the United States) care?

I believe it should (always and ever) come down to a test of 'what is best for the consumer'. I suggest that the only lobby group worth listening to is the consumer. Maybe all politicians should take heed of that? It sounds so good, I'll say it again, "The only lobby group worth listening to is the consumer". 

Why is that true? It's true, because Parliament or Congress is elected to represent the interests of the people (at least in a Democracy) and should make it their business to do just that. Consumers need legal protection from harmful and anticompetitive conduct and assurances that they will be treated fairly, in terms of clear and unambiguous billing, for example. 

The problem is that the majority of lobbyists (be it to Congress in Washington, Parliament in Westminster or the European Commission in Brussels) represent vested interests. By which I mean vendor interests and significantly influential vendors at that. Of course, the vendors' viewpoint needs to be aired, however that should be done more openly. Congressional working groups, for example, could invite vendor submissions - and share them in public. 

My final thought is that this should be enshrined in law, such that the only groups legally entitled to lobby shall be those representing the consumer. Power to the people!
| 0 Comments | 0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to sites that reference Power to the People:

Power to the People TrackBack URL : http://blog.tmcnet.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/42563

Around TMCnet:

Leave a comment

Recent Comments

  • Houston CRM: Integrated communication is the new wave and it benefits any read more
  • los angeles unified communications: Having all types of communication integrated makes things so much read more
  • Kevin Rodak: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eff7M9EZYPc Leaked military protoype test video ... lots of capability read more
  • Eddie Marietta: Extremely useful and informative article. I wish i can do read more
  • Erin Locknane: Stumbled into this site by chance but I’m sure glad read more
  • David: This is good information on FoIP, and you may want read more
  • Jules Turnner: Good job! read more
  • Ebonie Behrman: Awesome blog! read more
  • Aculab: Steve, Interesting scenario you have, and I am sure one read more
  • Steve Klinger: Hello Andrew, We have 14 offices across the world with read more

Subscribe to Blog


Recent Entry Images

  • zeus
  • evolution.jpg
  • Traditional_vs_cloud_based_deployments.png
  • Prosody X - boxed
  • Telephony_paas2.jpg

Recent Activity


  • Aculab tweeted, "New Blog: 'The kiss of life for caller authentication' Ian Colville explores the benefits #voicebiometrics bring to caller authentication; how to address common challenges & how to deliver a #secure and efficient CX #VoiSentryhttp://ow.ly/fHAA50v11oB "


  • Aculab tweeted, "If you're thinking about adding #voicebiometrics to your contact centre or customer service application, this guide will help with areas such as user enrolment, multi-factor authentication & handling identity claims #CustomerExperience #HearTheDifference http://ow.ly/Fdn150uYuc7 pic.twitter.com/RBOruUpV75"


  • Aculab tweeted, "Welcome #VoiSentry from @aculab to the DevConnect Marketplace! VoiSentry is voice biometrics tech that enables speaker verification, cost-effectively, to virtually any telephony-based application. https://www.devconnectmarketplace.com/marketplace/aculab/voisentry …"




  • Aculab tweeted, ".@aculab voice #biometrics solution now ‘Avaya Compliant’https://www.biometricupdate.com/201906/aculabs-voice-biometric-solution-now-avaya-compliant …"


  • Aculab tweeted, "Lab-quality voice recordings can be used to accurately identify people diagnosed with Parkinson's disease. These researchers made these assessments more cost-effective and practical by using telephone-quality recordings: https://doi.org/10.1121/1.5100272 … @SomervilleOx @aculab @EdinUniUsherpic.twitter.com/ZoJ9ktJlnW"
  • Aculab tweeted, "Check out the FindBiometrics Directory where you'll find the leading solution providers for #financial, #enterprise, #government, #healthcare biometrics and more! @Neurotec @AimBrainHQ @innovatrics @aculab @AratekBio @Veratad http://ow.ly/V6eU50uyYeq pic.twitter.com/j9RFOgcvPt"


Around TMCnet Blogs

Latest Whitepapers

TMCnet Videos